|
|
|
|
|
|
For a printable version of this information click here.
| Brief description |
|
Questionnaires are written documents that record
responses to a set of pre-determined questions. The
same questions are asked of all respondents (unless
respondents skip specific questions for which they
do not qualify). Questionnaires can have different
forms of distribution:
- Mail (you mail it to people and ask them to return
it - usually in pre-paid envelopes)
- Telephone
- Face-to-face (eg: at a local supermarket, door-to-door)
- Email (eg: some council websites have interactive
pages. For more information see our section on e-consultation
A questionnaire may be targeted at a specific group
(eg: users of a facility or service) or the general
population.
A sample (the people you interview) for a questionnaire
can be random (ie: you do not know who people are)
or targeted (ie: identified users of a service).
|
| To what kinds of consultation situations is this
approach best suited? |
|
Questionnaires are excellent in the following situations:
- When you require statistically significant responses.
- When you require feedback from a large group of
people in a short time-frame.
- When you have a limited budget (eg: if you arrange
your own mail-out process).
- When you require some straight-forward responses
on an issue (yes/no information).
- When you are interested in "rating"
a service or program provided by your council and
tracking this rating over time.
|
| How much time is generally needed? |
|
Time is dependent on the sample size, form of
distribution and who is doing the work (you or a specialist
market research agency). A specialist agency could
turn around a 300-sample survey in three to four weeks.
When you mail out a questionnaire, you will need
to have a couple of weeks "turn-around"
just for people to complete it and send it back (which
does not take into account the time needed for questionnaire
design and analysis). Similarly with email, you will
need to leave time for people to complete the questionnaire
and return it.
Telephone and face-to-face questionnaires are quicker
as the surveys are undertaken on the spot.
|
| What sorts of skills are required? |
|
Some market research or statistical skills are an
advantage if you are going to undertake the survey
design and data analysis internally.
If you are using an external specialist agency to
undertake the work, standard project management skills
are required.
|
| What kind of information do participants require
prior to their involvement? |
| A self-completion questionnaire should have an explanation
on the front identifying why the survey is being conducted,
who is conducting it and how the data will be used.
If the survey is being conducted over the phone or face-to-face
this information should be provided at the start of
the interview. |
| Brief outline of how the process usually works |
|
The key steps in conducting a questionnaire are as
follows:
- Confirm objectives and outcomes
- Develop questionnaire
- Determine sample size
- Prepare sample (mail-out, phone numbers etc)
- Distribute questionnaire
- Coding and editing of returned questionnaires
- Data analysis
- Report preparation
- Report presentation
- Feedback to participants.
Steps 2 to 10 (all or individual components) can
be undertaken by a specialist agency if funds are
available.
Specific tips about using a questionnaire follow.
Once you have completed an appropriate number of
questionnaires (see sample size below), the respondents'
answers must be recorded and collated by a central
source (either manually or using a computer). Collation
of data can be done internally (manually or using
a PC-based data analysis package such as SPSS) or
externally (paying a specialist market research agency).
A questionnaire will have two types of questions.
These are referred to as "open-ended" questions
or "closed" questions.
Open-ended questions are used when you want detailed
descriptions of respondents' feelings about a matter
or when you don't have any preconceived ideas of what
type of responses people may have. Closed questions
are used when you have a good idea of the types of
responses you will get and you can make up your own
code frame.
For an example of a questionnaire with both type
of questions click here.
Questions 2, 3 and 4 are examples of closed questions.
Questions 6b and 11b are examples of open-ended questions.
Anyone can design a questionnaire with practice (so
don't think that you will always have to use a specialist
agency). Some tricks of the trade are:
- Learn from example - there are good questionnaires
everywhere (on the internet, used by other councils,
sent to you in the mail). Borrow the questions and
the structures.
- Keep it simple and test it on a lot of people
(a question may make sense to you but may be very
confusing to others).
Sample sizes depend on a number of factors.
Does it need to be statistically significant? Are
you interested in interviewing all customers for a
specific service? How much money is in my budget?
Some broad figures on sample sizes are as follows:
- Sample size of 400 (where universe is over 100,000)
will have a margin of error of +/- 5%.
- Sample size of 100 (where universe is over 100,000)
will have a margin of error of +/- 10%.
|
| How is this approach usually evaluated? |
|
You can evaluate how successful your questionnaire
has been by assessing the following:
- Number of returns
- Level of information provided (ie: detail of responses)
- Amount of useful data (ie: information you could
use in future decision-making processes.)
|
| Strengths |
- People (eg: community/councillors) seem to be
more willing to accept/respond to survey results,
as long as you can show a reasonable sample size.
- Questionnaires may be distributed
to a broad sample of residents, not just the "usual
suspects" who might regularly participate in
public forums.
- Once you have a bit of experience designing questionnaires
you can continue to use successful questionnaires
and methodologies, reducing time and resources.
- Not too time consuming for respondents (i.e. they
can complete at home in own time if a mail out)
|
| Weaknesses |
- Can be confronting to undertake if you have little
experience in the area and do not have any funds
available for expert advice/support.
- They take a few weeks (minimum) to turn around.
- Self-completion formats are not as effective for
older people, people with disabilities or people
from culturally and linguistically diverse backgrounds,
unless you provide surveys in other languages. In
these circumstances, face-to-face surveys are better.
- The information you obtain will only be as good/useful
as the questions asked.
|
| Resources required |
|
questionnaires can be developed, compiled and
analysed at a desk.
The distribution of the questionnaire requires desks/phones
etc if you are going to employ people to conduct the
interviews by telephone.
Sometimes an incentive may be used to encourage people
to respond. This can be anything from a cash prize
to a month's free use of the local sports centre.
The costs of conducting surveys have a number of
key variables which make it difficult to provide estimates.
These include:
- Whether the work is completed internally or specialist
agencies/consultants are employed.
- The size of the sample.
- The length and complexity of the questionnaire.
- The format for distribution (ie: mail out/telephone
etc)
- The number of "open-ended" compared
with "closed" questions (open-ended questions
need to be coded and edited for analysis).
- The existence of internal analysis packages (ie:
SPSS).
For example, a 15-minute telephone survey with 300
people conducted by a specialist agency would cost
over $10,000 (estimate only).
However, a mail-out questionnaire prepared and analysed
in-house would only cost the staff time plus the stamps/self-addressed
envelopes.
Key punching and data analysis undertaken by an external
agency (you prepare the questionnaires and send them
to the agency for analysis once completed) may only
cost between $500 and $1000, depending on how many
questionnaires and the complexity of the survey).
|
Information provided by Pia Borghesi, Coordinator of Community
Planning, Maroondah City Council.
CASE STUDY
| Council or other authority |
| Mornington Peninsula Shire Council |
| Name of Project |
| Peninsula Way Program Review Library Survey 2001 |
| Date of consultation |
| September 2001 |
| Aim of consultation |
| To obtain information about the type of library services
residents required, their expected standards of delivery
and any necessary improvements. |
| Consultation methods used |
| Self-administered survey or by interview with a library
staff member. |
| Description of consultation |
|
The survey was conducted in four library branches,
the mobile library service, community houses and shopping
centres in the shire. Library staff set up a table
at the local community market and conducted the survey
in a couple of local shopping centres. An article
on the survey and how people could respond was in
the September 2001 edition of Peninsula Wide, a paper
distributed to all residents and property owners in
the shire. The library web-site had an electronic
version of the survey.
A six-page questionnaire was conducted, containing
15 questions on opening hours, services, purchasing
priorities and improvement suggestions.
We planned to survey 1000 library users and non-users
and 1,107 people completed the survey, including six
electronically. Library staff helped about 60 people
fill in the questions, spending about 15 minutes with
each.
Respondents were from all areas of the shire, including
29 from outside the shire, and 86% were library users
while 14% were not. Two-thirds of respondents were
women and 58% were aged between 36 and 70.
|
| Success of the consultation |
|
This consultation built on a customer satisfaction
survey held in November 2000 which showed an overall
community satisfaction level of 98.3%.
The library team asked about areas where they thought
the service could be improved. Specific questions
covered:
- Opening hours - 68% want the library open on Mondays
(when it is currently closed).
- Why people didn't use the library - three per
cent said they were not aware of the library service
and 8.6% were not aware of the mobile library.
- What was least popular about the current service
- over 520 responses included concerns such as limited
hours, an old, cramped and stuffy building and limited
resources.
- What services could the library improve - 130
responses included opening earlier and extending
the loan period.
Library staff were asked how future consultations
with the community could be improved.
Suggestions included limiting the number of questions
asked, making the survey easier so people could fill
in their own or the survey being done entirely by
interview. The review team also noted that there was
little response from under-18- year-olds (only seven
per cent) and that this age group would be targeted
in future.
The survey was held over a month, which gave the
community enough time to respond but did not disrupt
the library service and staff for too long. Many people
said they were delighted to be able to give comments.
Feedback on the findings of the survey was presented
at the library branches and in the February 2002 edition
of Peninsula Wide.
|
| Other comments |
| A library survey will be conducted on a biennial basis,
which will enable trend data to be documented. |
| Contact person details: |
|
|
To view more case studies, click
here.
|
|

|
site
designed by
Infoxchange
Australia
|
|
|